On Halloween Jensen dares Jared to read something from an old book they find in the prop department on set. The next day they both wake up as cute, little fairies. Jensen is turning around again and again, trying to get a proper view of his ridiculous green wings. Meanwhile Jared secretly tries to check out, that yes, even as a fairy, he's still bigger then Jensen.

After the shock wears off, they try to find a way to turn back human again.